NCTJ Court Reporting Practice Exam

Can we publish backgrounders during the period between verdict and sentence?

1. No, judges could be biased

2. Yes, because it's the judge who decides the sentence

3. Yes, only if permission is granted

4. No, it is not allowed

The correct answer is: Yes, because it's the judge who decides the sentence

The correct answer affirms that it is permissible to publish backgrounders during the period between the verdict and the sentencing, emphasizing that the sentence is ultimately determined by the judge. This option acknowledges the role of the judge in the sentencing process, which means that the information presented in backgrounders would not necessarily influence the outcome, as judicial decisions are ideally made based on legal considerations rather than public opinion or media coverage. The period between a verdict and a sentencing is significant because the judge typically reviews various factors, including the nature of the crime, the defendant's background, and any mitigating or aggravating factors that may influence the sentence. Therefore, while the publication of backgrounders can occur, it is crucial that they are handled with care to ensure they do not contain prejudicial information that could undermine the fairness of the judicial process. Other choices suggest limitations that misconstrue the role of media during this phase. While concerns about bias are valid, the answer confirms that the judge has the ultimate discretion, making informed decisions based on established legal principles. The importance is placed on the integrity of the judicial process rather than an outright ban on publishing backgrounders.